Caps and Indemnities - A Founder's Guide to Capping Your Risk
Every contract you sign has two clauses that decide how much a deal can cost you if it goes wrong: the liability cap and the indemnity. Most founders copy both from the last deal and never look at them properly.
That's expensive. The two clauses pull against each other. A cap puts a ceiling on what you pay. An indemnity creates a promise to pay that wouldn't otherwise exist. If you don't link them, the indemnity quietly eats the cap.
Here's how to get them right under South African law.
The one question to ask first: does the cap cover the indemnity?
Most contracts answer this by accident. You have three options:
How you set it up | What it means for you | Use it when |
Indemnities sit inside the cap | You know your worst case | You're the supplier and your pricing assumes a ceiling |
Indemnities sit outside the cap | No ceiling on those risks | You're the customer worried about IP or data claims |
Indemnities get their own higher "super-cap" | A bigger number, but still a number | Most mid-market deals - usually the right answer |
Whatever you pick, say it in writing. A cap on "total liability under this Agreement" plus an indemnity that says nothing about the cap is an invitation to argue. Close the gap:
The cap in clause X applies to, and includes, the indemnities in clause Y, except that the indemnity in clause Y.3 (third-party IP infringement) has its own separate limit of R[●].
Building a cap that actually works
A cap is a set of decisions, not one number.
Pick the number carefully. "Fees paid in the last 12 months" is the market standard. But decide: fees paid or fees payable? Rolling 12 months or contract year? Watch the trap - after a cheap one-year pilot, a fees-based cap can be almost nothing in month two. Add a floor: "the greater of R500,000 or 12 months' fees."
Make it a total, not per claim. A per-claim cap on a long contract is barely a cap at all.
Check it works both ways. If your liability is capped, is theirs? The customer's duty to pay you must sit outside its own cap, or the cap becomes permission not to pay.
Don't rely on "consequential loss." South African law has no tidy category with that name, and courts decide recoverability using the contemplation rules from Holmdene Brickworks v Roberts Construction 1977 (3) SA 670 (A). So list what you actually mean: lost profit, lost revenue, lost savings, goodwill, wasted spend, lost data. Then say whether those are excluded even when they're direct losses.
Line it up with your insurance. Setting a cap below the cover you already pay for throws away protection. Super-caps in mid-market deals are usually two to three times the general cap, or your insured limit.
Keep the usual carve-outs outside the cap. Fraud, death or injury caused by negligence, wilful misconduct, breach of confidentiality (often capped separately), IP infringement, payment obligations, and anything the law won't let you limit.
What the law lets a cap do - and what it doesn't
South African courts will enforce caps. Freedom of contract is the starting point: in Afrox Healthcare Bpk v Strydom 2002 (6) SA 21 (SCA) a hospital's exemption clause was upheld despite unequal bargaining power. Three limits matter in practice.
1. Public policy. In Barkhuizen v Napier (CC, 2007) the Constitutional Court said a term won't be enforced if enforcing it would offend public policy. Beadica 231 CC v Trustees for the time being of the Oregon Trust (CC, 2020) narrowed this: fairness and good faith aren't free passes out of a bad bargain - deals are meant to be kept. But in Naidoo v Birchwood Hotel (2012) a court refused to enforce a hotel's exclusion against a guest badly hurt by a falling gate, even though she'd signed. A signature doesn't end the argument. The broader and more absolute your exclusion - especially for injury - the shakier it is. A cap agreed between two businesses will usually stand.
2. Courts read exclusions narrowly. In Van der Westhuizen v Arnold (SCA, 2002) a blanket "no warranties whatsoever" clause failed to exclude the warranty against eviction, because it didn't say so clearly. Contracts are now read as text, context and purpose together (Natal Joint Municipal Pension Fund v Endumeni Municipality (SCA, 2012); University of Johannesburg v Auckland Park Theological Seminary (CC, 2021)), with Capitec Bank Holdings v Coral Lagoon Investments 194 2022 (1) SA 100 (SCA) warning courts not to rewrite clear wording. If you want to exclude something, name it. Catch-alls are the weakest drafting you can use.
3. The Consumer Protection Act 68 of 2008. This catches far more B2B deals than founders expect. Under section 5(2)(b), a company customer only falls outside the Act if its assets or turnover exceed the threshold - currently R2 million. Sell to small businesses and your "commercial" terms are consumer terms:
Section 48 bans unfair, unreasonable or unjust terms, including unfair limits on your liability.
Section 49 says any term limiting your liability, shifting risk, imposing an indemnity or recording an acknowledgement must be in plain language and brought to the customer's attention before the deal. Section 49(2) goes further: you must explain its nature and effect, and the customer must sign or initial it. A sign on the wall is not enough.
Section 51 makes some terms void outright - including any attempt to exclude liability for your own gross negligence.
Section 61 imposes strict liability for harm from unsafe or defective goods, whether or not you were negligent (limited defences in section 61(4)), and section 51 stops you contracting out of it.
Practical rule: never use the same limitation clause for business and consumer customers. In consumer terms, separate it out, bold it, show it before acceptance, and keep proof of how you presented it.
Indemnities: the mechanics matter more than the trigger
Most indemnity fights are about process, not principle. An indemnity is a direct promise to cover the other side, usually against third-party claims. Because it's a payment promise rather than a damages claim, a well-drafted indemnity can sidestep arguments about remoteness and mitigation - how far, in South African law, isn't settled, and depends on your wording. That's exactly why counterparties resist them.
Keep indemnities for third-party claims. An indemnity covering the other side's own losses is a back door around the normal damages rules. Their own losses belong under the cap.
Choose your heads deliberately. Usual suspects: third-party IP infringement; data protection breaches; injury and property damage on site; employee and contractor claims (watch section 198A(3)(b) of the Labour Relations Act, confirmed in Assign Services (Pty) Ltd v NUMSA (CC, 2018)); taxes and levies.
Say how claims get run. Notice period and what the notice must say; whether late notice kills the claim (prefer "only to the extent it caused prejudice"); who runs the defence; whether they can settle without you; the duty to cooperate; no admitting liability.
Cut it down for their own fault. Reduce the indemnity to the extent their negligence or breach caused the loss, and deduct insurance payouts and recovered tax.
Deal with legal costs and tax. Say whether costs are covered on an attorney-and-client scale and whether payment is made without deductions.
Block double recovery. If one loss is both a breach of warranty and an indemnified claim, say that recovering under one reduces the other.
Be careful with fines. Indemnities for regulatory fines - POPIA penalties under section 109, competition penalties - may be unenforceable because they undermine the point of the fine, and are often uninsurable. No South African court has decided this yet. Treat it as an open risk: draft it explicitly, price it, and don't assume it holds.
Five mistakes to avoid
Capping liability, then leaving an uncapped indemnity elsewhere. The cap becomes decoration.
Writing "consequential loss" without ever defining what's excluded.
Using one limitation clause for both consumer and business customers, ignoring CPA sections 48, 49 and 51.
Indemnities with no notice, claims-control or mitigation mechanics.
Relying on broad catch-alls when courts read them narrowly. Name what you mean to exclude.
Caps and indemnities are how you price risk. Before signing, give the draft to someone who wasn't in the negotiation and ask two questions: what is the most we could have to pay, and which risks sit outside that number? If they can't answer in under a minute without arguing, the clause needs more work.
Contact an expert at SchoemanLaw Inc to assist.
https://schoemanlaw.co.za/services/commercial-law/
https://schoemanlaw.co.za/services/contract-drafting/
https://schoemanlaw.co.za/services/technology-law/
Nicolene Schoeman-Louw | SchoemanLaw Inc
Specialist Technology, Commercial and Contract Law
Release information
Issued on behalf of
SchoemanLaw Inc.
Media contact
SchoemanLaw Inc
SchoemanLaw Inc