Can I Change My Child’s School Without the Other Parent’s Consent? A South African family law overview
Few parenting decisions cause as much conflict after separation as the choice of a school. One parent may want to move the child to a school closer to home, a better-resourced school or a school that suits the child’s needs, while the other parent objects, or simply refuses to engage. The question parents then ask is: “Can I change my child’s school without the other parent’s consent?”
The answer is not a simple yes or no. It depends on who holds parental responsibilities and rights, what any parenting plan or court order says, how the Children’s Act 38 of 2005 treats “major decisions”, and, above all, what is in the child’s best interests.
Parental responsibilities and rights
Section 28(2) of the Constitution provides that a child’s best interests are of paramount importance in every matter concerning the child. The Children’s Act gives effect to this principle by regulating parental responsibilities and rights, which include the responsibility and right to care for the child, maintain contact with the child, act as guardian, and contribute to the child’s maintenance.
A mother acquires full parental responsibilities and rights on the birth of the child, as does a married father. An unmarried father acquires them by agreement, by court order, or where he meets the requirements of section 21 of the Act. Where more than one person holds these rights, they are co-holders, and each may generally exercise them without the others’ consent unless the Act, a court order or an agreement provides otherwise. Having primary care of a child, in other words, does not automatically give one parent the final say on every decision.
Joint decision-making and major decisions
Sections 30 and 31 of the Children’s Act deal with the co-exercise of parental responsibilities and rights. Before a parent makes a major decision involving the child, that parent must give due consideration to the views and wishes of any other co-holder, and to the views of the child, taking into account the child’s age, maturity and stage of development. Certain decisions, such as removing a child from the Republic or applying for a child’s passport, require the consent of every guardian.
Co-holders are encouraged to reach agreement, and a parenting plan is the best place to record how decisions about schooling, religion, medical treatment and relocation will be made. Where a parenting plan or court order expressly requires both parents to agree before the school is changed, one parent cannot ignore that term.
Is a change of school a “major decision”?
A change of school is clearly an important decision, because it affects the child’s stability, friendships, routine, travel time and long-term development. Many parents therefore assume that both must consent.
A parent who changes the school without consulting the other parent, without a good reason, or contrary to an existing order or parenting plan risks a contempt application, an adverse costs order, or a finding that he or she is unwilling to co-parent. The safer course is always to consult, document the reasons and, if agreement is not reached, ask the court to decide.
When parents cannot agree
Where parents are deadlocked, the dispute should be resolved by a structured process rather than a unilateral move. Courts and practitioners generally look at factors such as:
The child’s educational, emotional and social needs, and the reasons for the proposed change.
The distance and travel time between the child’s home, the school and the other parent’s home.
The impact of the move on the child’s stability, friendships and performance at school.
The child’s own views, given appropriate weight according to age and maturity.
The practical and financial feasibility of the proposed school, including fees.
Whether each parent has genuinely engaged with the other’s views.
Mediation, parenting coordination or the involvement of the Family Advocate can help to resolve the matter early. Where that fails, a parent may approach the High Court (or another competent court) for an order authorising the change of school and, if necessary, dispensing with the other parent’s consent. Where the matter is urgent, for example because the school year is about to begin, the application can be brought on an urgent basis.
Maintenance is not a reason to refuse consent
A parent may not withhold consent to a change of school in order to pressure the other parent about unpaid maintenance, or vice versa. Concerns about school fees and affordability are legitimate, but they must be dealt with in the appropriate forum, such as a maintenance application or enforcement proceedings, and not at the expense of the child’s daily welfare.
What should a parent do before changing a school?
A parent who wishes to change a child’s school should act transparently and with proper preparation. Useful steps include:
Check any parenting plan, settlement agreement or court order for provisions on schooling and decision-making.
Inform the other parent in writing of the proposed change, with reasons, and invite his or her views.
Consider the child’s views and, where appropriate, obtain input from a psychologist, educator or other professional.
Keep a record of all communication, including the other parent’s response or lack of response.
Propose mediation or a parenting-plan amendment if there is disagreement.
Seek legal advice and, if necessary, apply to court before enrolling the child, rather than acting unilaterally.
What if there is no court order or parenting plan?
Where no order or parenting plan exists, both parents who hold parental responsibilities and rights remain entitled to be involved in the child’s upbringing, and the duty to consult applies. Because there is no document to enforce, disputes are more likely to arise and be harder to resolve. Parents are well advised to formalise their arrangements in a parenting plan that addresses schooling, extramural activities, transport, communication and how future disputes will be resolved.
Conclusion
A parent who wants to change a child’s school should not assume that the other parent’s consent is always required, nor that it can safely be ignored. The law expects parents to consult each other and to give due regard to each other’s views, and it provides the courts as the final decision-maker where agreement cannot be reached. Ultimately, the question is not which parent “wins”, but which school arrangement best serves the child’s welfare, stability and long-term well-being.
For further assistance, consult an attorney at SchoemanLaw.
https://schoemanlaw.co.za/our-services/family-law/
Robyn Shepherd | SchoemanLaw Inc
Attorney
Release information
Issued on behalf of
SchoemanLaw Inc
Media contact
SchoemanLaw Inc
SchoemanLaw Inc