Urgent Applications in South African Courts - The Requirements for Urgency and the Consequences of Failing to Establish It
Litigation is rarely quick, but some litigants cannot afford to wait for the ordinary court process. An urgent application asks the court to hear a matter on a shortened timetable, ahead of other matters, because waiting for a hearing in the ordinary course would cause harm that cannot later be remedied. In the High Court, such applications are brought in terms of Uniform Rule 6(12) and in the Magistrates’ Court in terms of Rule 55(5), which allows the court to dispense with the usual forms and time periods. This article briefly explains what the courts require and what may happen if urgency is not established.
To appreciate why urgent applications exist, one must understand the pressure on our courts. Court rolls are very full. In the usual course, a litigant who issues an application and has it opposed will have to wait several months, and in some instances perhaps even a year, before the matter is allocated a date and heard by the court.
For many disputes, this waiting period is inconvenient but tolerable. For others, such as where a property is about to be sold in execution, a business is about to lose its premises or a right is about to be permanently lost, a wait of this kind would render the eventual order meaningless. Urgent applications allow a litigant to bypass the queue, but only if the strict requirements for urgency are met.
Uniform Rule 6(12)
Rule 6(12) of the Uniform Rules of Court provides as follows:
“(a) In urgent applications the court or a judge may dispense with the forms and service provided for in these rules and may dispose of such matter at such time and place and in such manner and in accordance with such procedure (which shall as far as practicable be in terms of these rules) as it deems fit.
(b) In every affidavit filed in support of any application under paragraph (a) of this subrule, the applicant shall set forth explicitly the circumstances which it is averred render the matter urgent and the reasons why the applicant claims that applicant could not be afforded substantial redress at a hearing in due course.
(c) A person against whom an order was granted in such person’s absence in an urgent application may by notice, set down the matter for reconsideration of the order.”
In practical terms, Rule 6(12) gives the court discretion to relax the Rules so that a genuinely urgent matter can be heard sooner and on shorter notice, but it does not give the applicant a right to jump the queue. The applicant carries the burden of setting out, in the founding affidavit itself, the specific circumstances that render the matter urgent and why substantial redress could not be obtained at a hearing in due course.
Practitioners should have regard to Luna Meubel Vervaardigers (Edms) Bpk v Makin and Another (t/a Makin’s Furniture Manufacturers) 1977 (4) SA 135 (W), where the court emphasised that practitioners should carefully determine whether greater or lesser degree of relaxation of the Rules and practice of the Court is required. The degree of relaxation should not be greater than the exigency of the case demands. The court held that an applicant must make out a case in the founding affidavit to justify the particular extent of the departure from the norm, including the time and day on which the matter is set down.
In East Rock Trading 7 (Pty) Ltd and Others v Eagle Valley Granite (Pty) Ltd and Others [2011] ZAGPJHC 196, Notshe AJ, with reference to Rule 12(6)(b), said:
”The import thereof is that the procedure set out in rule 6(12) is not there for taking. An applicant has to set forth explicitly the circumstances which he avers render the matter urgent. More importantly, the Applicant must state the reasons why he claims that he cannot be afforded substantial redress at a hearing in due course. The question of whether a matter is sufficiently urgent to be enrolled and heard as an urgent application is underpinned by the issue of absence of substantial redress in an application in due course. The rules allow the court to come to the assistance of a litigant because if the latter were to wait for the normal course laid down by the rules it will not obtain substantial redress.
Notshe AJ further stated that:
”The correct and the crucial test is whether, if the matter were to follow its normal course as laid down by the rules, an Applicant will be afforded substantial redress. If he cannot be afforded substantial redress at a hearing in due course then the matter qualifies to be enrolled and heard as an urgent application. If however despite the anxiety of an Applicant he can be afforded a substantial redress in an application in due course the application does not qualify to be enrolled and heard as an urgent application.”
An applicant who fails to set out satisfactory reasons for urgency risks having the matter struck from the roll. The usual order of striking from the roll lets the applicant set the matter down again, on proper notice and in compliance with the rules. In practice, that means enrolling it in the ordinary course, on the opposed motion roll, where it gets a normal hearing date. The applicant may also be ordered to pay the respondent’s costs for opposing the urgent application and, in appropriate cases, those costs may be awarded on a punitive scale.
Finally, rule 6(12)(c) protects a party against whom an order was granted in their absence, as such a party may set the matter down for reconsideration.
Urgent applications in the Magistrates Court
Urgent relief is not limited to the High Court. The Magistrates’ Courts have a similar procedure in Rule 55(5) of the Magistrates’ Courts Rules. In urgent applications, the court may dispense with the forms and service provided for in the Rules and may deal with the matter at such time and place, and in such manner and in accordance with such procedure, as it deems fit. As far as practicable, the procedure must still follow the Rules.
As in the High Court, the application must be supported by an affidavit that explicitly sets out the circumstances which the applicant avers render the matter urgent. It must also set out the reasons why the applicant claims that substantial redress could not be obtained at a hearing in due course. A bare allegation that the matter is urgent will not be enough.
Unlike the High Court, which has inherent jurisdiction to regulate its own process, the Magistrates’ Courts are creatures of statute. They have only the jurisdiction and powers conferred on them by the Magistrates’ Courts Act 32 of 1944 and the Rules made under it, and urgency cannot enlarge those powers. Rule 55(5) allows a court to relax the forms and time periods, but it does not extend the court’s jurisdiction or its power to grant a particular remedy. An applicant must therefore first confirm that the relief sought falls within the court’s jurisdiction in respect of persons, area and cause of action, and that it is not one of the matters that section 46 of the Act places beyond the court’s jurisdiction. The power to grant interdicts is itself regulated by section 30 of the Act. Where the relief sought is outside these limits, the application may be dismissed or struck from the roll however pressing the circumstances, and the applicant may have to approach the High Court instead.
What constitutes urgency?
There is no closed list of urgent matters. Urgency depends on the facts of each case and on whether the applicant can obtain substantial redress at a hearing in due course. The following examples illustrate situations in which the courts have generally been receptive to urgent relief:
a property that is about to be sold in execution, so that the applicant will lose it before the ordinary application can be heard;
a threatened eviction, or the loss of business premises, where a delay would leave the applicant without a home or without a place from which to trade;
unlawful dispossession (spoliation), where the applicant has been deprived of possession and seeks the immediate restoration of possession;
a threat to dispose of or dissipate assets, so that a later order would be of no practical value;
conduct that is continuing and causing harm that cannot later be undone or compensated, such as the disclosure of confidential information or the cutting off of an essential service; and
a threat to the safety or welfare of a person, including a child, which cannot wait for the ordinary court process.
By contrast, the following will ordinarily not qualify as urgent on their own:
a financial loss that can be quantified and recovered later by way of damages;
inconvenience, or the anxiety of the applicant, without a real risk of harm that cannot be remedied later; and
urgency that the applicant created by waiting, without explanation, before approaching the court.
The importance of explaining why substantial redress cannot be obtained in due course
The phrase “substantial redress” is not defined in the Rules, but its meaning is clear from the case law. It does not mean that the applicant must be guaranteed a perfect outcome, or that a later hearing would give the applicant nothing at all. The question is whether, if the matter follows its normal course, the applicant will still be able to obtain an effective remedy, in other words an order that adequately protects or restores the right in issue. If the answer is yes, the matter is not urgent, even though the applicant may be inconvenienced, anxious or put to expense while waiting. If the answer is no, because by the time the matter is heard the harm will have been done and cannot be undone or fairly compensated, the applicant has a basis for urgent relief.
This is why Rule 6(12)(b) requires the applicant to deal with the issue explicitly. The applicant must set out two separate things in the founding affidavit: the circumstances which render the matter urgent, and the reasons why substantial redress could not be obtained at a hearing in due course.
In practice, a good founding affidavit will state what will happen if the matter is not heard urgently, when it will happen, and why an order granted at a later hearing could not reverse it or compensate for it. Dates and specific consequences carry far more weight than general statements of prejudice. An applicant who does not provide this explanation risks having the application struck from the roll, with the costs consequences discussed below.
Self-created urgency
This is perhaps the ground on which most urgent applications fail.
If a respondent can show that the applicant was aware of the legal issue for some time and failed to take steps until harm became imminent, the applicant will have a hard time explaining why the matter must be heard urgently.
A delay is not always fatal. An applicant who has acted reasonably, for example by trying to resolve the dispute through correspondence or negotiation, gathering the documents needed to bring the application or obtaining legal advice, may be able to show that urgency arose only when it became clear that the dispute could not be resolved or the threat became imminent. What matters is that the delay is explained in the founding affidavit, step by step, from the date on which the applicant first became aware of the threat until the date on which the application was launched. A general explanation will not suffice. An applicant who waits until the last moment and then asks the respondent and the court to work to a drastically shortened timetable will usually fail.
Conclusion
Urgent applications are an important tool for litigants who cannot wait for the ordinary court process, but they are an exception and not a shortcut. Whether in the High Court or the Magistrates’ Courts, the applicant must show in the founding affidavit that the matter is urgent and that substantial redress cannot be obtained at a hearing in due course, before the court will consider the merits. Urgency that the applicant created by delay will not assist. An applicant who fails to make out a proper case risks having the matter struck from the roll and being ordered to pay costs. Careful preparation and early legal advice are therefore essential.
Contact an expert at SchoemanLaw Inc in Cape Town or Paarl for assistance with your legal needs.
https://schoemanlaw.co.za/services/litigation-and-dispute-resolution/
Janet Mc Intosh | SchoemanLaw Inc
Attorney: Civil and Commercial Litigation
Release information
Issued on behalf of
SchoemanLaw Inc
Media contact
SchoemanLaw Inc
SchoemanLaw Inc