Skip to content

Why community loyalty is becoming a gym's most valuable business asset

20 November 20266 min
Submitted by: Kerry Du Toit
Why community loyalty is becoming a gym's most valuable business asset

As South Africans become more selective about their monthly spending, Purpose Fit co-owner Sheldon Castle believes independent fitness businesses can build stronger, more sustainable revenue by investing in the members they already have.

In a market where 28% of South African consumers have cancelled subscriptions or memberships, the smartest growth strategy for fitness businesses may no longer be about signing up more people, but giving existing members compelling reasons to stay. With gym fees rising 10.5% in the year to October 2025, recurring revenue has become increasingly dependent on loyalty, consistent engagement and the value members attach to their training experience. For Sheldon Castle, co-owner of Cape Town-based fitness studio Purpose Fit, this represents a significant commercial opportunity for independent operators willing to build their businesses around relationships rather than recruitment targets.

The financial argument is difficult to ignore. According to TransUnion's Q2 2026 Consumer Pulse study, 53% of South African consumers reduced discretionary spending, while 28% cancelled subscriptions or memberships. Against this backdrop, businesses relying heavily on new customer acquisition face a costly cycle of replacing departing customers instead of building on the revenue they already generate.

The economics are particularly relevant in the fitness industry. In the first nine months of 2023, a prominent global gym franchise operating in South Africa sold approximately 170,000 memberships, yet recorded net membership growth of only 31,000, according to figures reported by Brait. The substantial difference illustrates how strong sales activity does not necessarily translate into equally strong membership growth.

For Castle, the more valuable measure of business performance is not simply how many people join, but whether they stay and remain engaged.

“Anyone can celebrate a busy January, but the real financial strength of a fitness business is measured by what happens for the rest of the year. Every member who stays contributes to revenue stability, every referral reduces the pressure on marketing spend, and every lasting relationship strengthens the business. Growth should not mean constantly replacing people. It should mean building something people genuinely want to remain part of,” says Castle.

At Purpose Fit, situated in Stonewood in Cape Town's Northern Suburbs, this thinking shapes a fitness offering centred on coached team training, personalised attention and shared accountability. Rather than competing solely on facilities or membership volume, the studio focuses on creating a training environment where individual progress and community connection form part of the value proposition.

The approach is reflected in the studio’s numbers. Purpose Fit’s monthly membership churn rate is 2.2%, well below the 5% to 8% typical across the fitness industry. Between two and five new members sign up each month through referrals from existing members, most of them through the studio’s buddy weeks and open Saturday workouts. Members also use what they pay for: 47% train consistently at the studio throughout the week. Castle puts these results down to a deliberate move away from paid Meta advertising towards organic content and affinity marketing. Under this approach, members bring in friends and family they know will suit the studio’s non-competitive training, which focuses on looking good, moving well and training without pain. Every key performance metric has improved since the switch.

The strategy speaks to a wider principle in subscription-based business models. Retaining an established customer helps protect recurring income, while referrals can create a more efficient route to acquiring new customers. Together, these factors can improve revenue predictability and reduce dependence on continuous promotional activity.

Castle believes bespoke fitness communities have a particular advantage because their size allows them to build closer relationships with members and respond more personally to their goals.

“In a large entity, it's easy for a customer to become another membership number. In an independent studio, you have the opportunity to understand why someone joined, what they are working towards and what motivates them to keep showing up. That personal connection has real commercial value because it builds trust, consistency and a sense of belonging that cannot simply be replicated through a marketing campaign,” he explains.

The strength of that connection becomes particularly visible in the relationships members build with one another. Shared training sessions, individual milestones and mutual encouragement can turn a fitness membership into an established part of someone's weekly routine and social network.

“What’s kept me at Purpose Fit is the people. The trainers know me and my family, they check in on us and they adapt the workouts when we need it. I feel like they know me as a person, and that makes me want to keep showing up. You train alongside people of all ages and fitness levels, and everyone has a place there. I always leave in a better mood.”

Storm Goosen, Purpose Fit member since 2023

For Castle, these relationships are not merely an added benefit of the training experience. They are central to how an independent studio creates differentiation in a competitive market.

“When members feel connected to the people around them, they are investing in more than access to a workout. They are investing in a routine, a support system and a community that wants to see them succeed. That is where loyalty starts to become a genuine business advantage. People stay because they see value in being there, and they recommend the experience because they believe in it,” says Castle.

That distinction is increasingly important as South Africans assess the value of recurring monthly expenses. Businesses that successfully become part of customers' everyday lives have an opportunity to build stronger loyalty without relying exclusively on price promotions or short-term incentives.

It also challenges the traditional perception that business growth must be driven primarily by expanding the customer base. For independent operators, sustainable growth can come from improving the value of existing relationships, extending membership tenure and encouraging organic recommendations.

“Community is often spoken about as something emotional, but from a business perspective it can be one of your strongest assets. Loyalty supports recurring revenue, referrals create opportunities for growth, and members who feel genuinely valued become advocates for your brand. You cannot build a sustainable business on sign-ups alone. You build it by giving people a reason to keep choosing you,” Castle adds.

As fitness businesses plan for 2027, Purpose Fit's approach highlights an increasingly relevant growth strategy for South African entrepreneurs. Customer relationships are not separate from commercial performance. When developed consistently, they can become the foundation of a more resilient business model.

Purpose Fit is inviting Northern Suburbs residents to book a free introductory training session at its Stonewood studio during November, subject to availability. To learn more or arrange a visit, go to purpose-fit.co.za or email This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..

Release information

Issued on behalf of

KDT Agency PTY Ltd

0828811843

Media contact

KDT Agency (PTY) Ltd

Kerry Du Toit

0828811843