Rainmaker Media Urges Standardised Incrementality Measurement for South African Retail Media
As incrementality becomes the next frontier of retail media measurement, South Africa also needs greater transparency and standardised measurement to allow advertisers to meaningfully compare performance.
One of retail media’s biggest advantages has always been its measurability. The ability to connect media exposure to actual shopping behaviour gives advertisers greater visibility into what happens after someone sees an ad, and whether that exposure ultimately translates into a sale.
But as the South African retail media market matures, the measurement conversation needs to mature with it.
Asks the harder question
Attribution can tell us that someone saw an ad and subsequently bought the product. Incrementality asks a harder question: did the advertising change their behaviour and generate a sale that would otherwise not have happened?
Take a basic FMCG purchase such as milk. If a customer buys milk every week, sees an ad and then buys a carton again, we may be able to attribute that sale to the advertising. But would they have bought the milk anyway?
This distinction is key because the value of retail media should ultimately lie not only in connecting exposure to transactions, but in understanding the difference advertising actually made.
Andrew Brand: Advertising has a job to do. Advertising has lost its way.
Andrew Brand 3 daysMeasuring what changed
Incrementality attempts to isolate that difference by comparing the behaviour of customers exposed to advertising with members in the same group who were not.
Online, we achieve this through holdout groups, where a portion of our target audience is withheld from advertising exposure and their subsequent behaviour is compared with the exposed group over the same period.
However, the principle becomes more complex in a physical retail environment. If advertising runs in one store, for example, a control store needs to provide a credible like-for-like comparison.
Comparing total store sales to the prior year or simply comparing the campaign period with the week before isn't sufficient – the relevant product sales need to be considered at SKU level over the same period, the stores themselves need to be sufficiently comparable, and other activity that could influence purchasing during the measurement period needs to be accounted for.
Sales and volume may also tell different stories if pricing changed during a campaign.
This is where incrementality becomes as much about methodology as the metric itself.
When the same metric means different things
As more retail media providers offer measures such as return on advertising spend (ROAS) and sales lift, advertisers also need to understand what sits behind those numbers.
Consider a snack brand running a retail media campaign over the same period as a major sporting event.
Sales during the campaign may be significantly higher than the week before, but we know occasions like this can influence purchasing behaviour in their own right.
Simply comparing the two periods and calling the difference “sales lift” doesn't tell us how much of that growth was actually generated by the advertising and how much was driven by the occasion itself.
The growing focus on incrementality is certainly not unique to South Africa.
According to NielsenIQ (NIQ) research, 67% of CMOs surveyed said they were increasing their retail media investment in 2026, reflecting the growing importance of the channel within advertising strategies.
As investment increases, so too does the need for robust, transparent measurement that gives advertisers confidence in the results.
For South Africa, where retail media is still developing as a category, this presents an opportunity to establish credible measurement practices as the market grows.
We already have sophisticated capabilities emerging locally, but greater alignment around definitions and methodologies will be important to ensure advertisers can evaluate performance consistently across different providers.
Building a common measurement language
At Rainmaker Media, we have invested significantly in developing measurement capability across online and offline environments. Our objective is to give advertisers information that helps them understand what worked and make better investment decisions.
For the wider industry, this means developing greater alignment around definitions and greater transparency around methodology.
When we talk about ROAS, attributed sales, sales lift or incrementality, advertisers should understand what those terms mean and have confidence in how they have been calculated – which is why MMA South Africa's work to develop a Retail Media Measurement Standard is an important step for the industry.
At Rainmaker, we have been actively involved in helping to shape this work through our participation in the industry's measurement committees, contributing our expertise to the development of more consistent and transparent measurement standards.
For a standard like this to work, however, it needs the participation of the whole industry, with brands, agencies, retailers and industry bodies all contributing to a shared framework that reflects the realities of the South African market.
Retail media has an opportunity to give advertisers a much clearer view of the impact their investment is really making, but that credibility depends on the industry being equally clear about how we arrive at those results.
If we can establish greater transparency and a common measurement language as the category develops, advertisers will be better equipped to compare apples with apples – or milk carton with milk carton – and ultimately make better investment decisions.