Skip to content

Trade Credit Fraud in South Africa - The Threat Hiding Behind the Credit Application

18 November 20264 min
Submitted by: Frank Knight, CEO of Debtsource

Fraud has always been a risk when businesses extend credit. What is changing, however, is the scale, sophistication and frequency with which fraudsters are targeting companies that sell goods and services on credit. Recent findings at Debtsource illustrate just how significant the threat has become. 

In the past 13 months, Debtsource has detected at least 318 incidents of suspected fraud, representing a combined potential financial exposure of approximately R655.3 million. These figures should concern every business that extends trade credit. Fraud is no longer an occasional anomaly within the credit department. It is becoming a material commercial risk that requires dedicated controls, verification processes, and ongoing vigilance.

Two fraud types dominate

Among the cases identified by Debtsource, two forms of fraud are particularly prevalent: commercial identity theft and scam businesses. Commercial identity theft occurs when fraudsters use the identity and credentials of an established, legitimate company to obtain credit from unsuspecting suppliers. Fraudsters may use genuine company registration information, VAT details, directors' names and other publicly available information while substituting false contact details, delivery addresses or banking information. To the credit grantor, the application can initially appear legitimate. 

The real company may have existed for many years and may have an excellent credit history. Goods are supplied based on that reputation, but are instead delivered to the fraudster, with payment never materialising. The second major threat is the scam business. Unlike commercial identity theft, where an existing company's identity is hijacked, a scam business may be specifically established or operated with the intention of obtaining goods or services on credit with no intention of paying for them.

These businesses can initially appear convincing. They may have professional websites, company registrations, email addresses, premises, and apparently legitimate references. Fraudsters increasingly understand how credit departments conduct their investigations and adapt their operations to exploit these processes.

Insurance is not a substitute for fraud prevention

One of the most important misconceptions for credit managers to understand is that having trade credit insurance does not necessarily protect a business against every fraudulent transaction.

Commercial identity theft is generally not an insurable credit loss under a traditional trade credit insurance policy. The insurer may have approved cover for the legitimate company, but if that company did not actually place the order or receive the goods, there may be no valid debt against the insured buyer. This distinction can leave the supplier carrying the entire loss.Trade credit insurance remains an extremely valuable tool for protecting businesses against genuine debtor default, but it should operate alongside robust fraud-prevention controls rather than replace them.

Verification has become essential

The most effective defence is to treat the information contained in a credit application as information that must be independently verified, rather than simply accepted at face value. Businesses should consider several practical controls:

  • Independently verify the applicant's contact details. Do not rely solely on telephone numbers, email addresses or websites provided on the credit application.
  • Confirm orders with established customers, particularly when there is a sudden change in purchasing behaviour, delivery location or order value.
  • Scrutinise email domains carefully. A domain that differs from the legitimate company's domain by a single letter may be enough to deceive an employee.
  • Verify delivery addresses, especially where goods are being delivered somewhere other than the customer's known premises.
  • Investigate unusual order patterns. Large first orders, urgent delivery requests, easily resalable goods and sudden requests for substantially higher credit limits should trigger additional verification.
  • Conduct ongoing credit monitoring. The risk does not end when the account is opened. Customer information and behaviour should be continuously assessed.
  • Train sales and credit teams together. Fraudsters frequently exploit the pressure to conclude a sale quickly. Fraud prevention cannot therefore be the responsibility of the credit department alone.

The cost of getting it wrong

The 318 incidents and R655.3 million in exposure identified over just 13 months highlight the scale of the threat facing businesses. Technology has made legitimate commerce faster, but it has also given fraudsters access to more company information and increasingly convincing ways of impersonating legitimate businesses. For credit grantors, the lesson is straightforward: know who you are really dealing with before releasing the goods. A credit check can tell you whether a company is creditworthy. Effective fraud prevention helps determine whether the company placing the order is who it claims to be. In today's environment, businesses need both.

Release information

Issued on behalf of

Debtsource

Media contact

Gillian Gamsy International Communications

Prudence Modjadji

011 728 1363